Tag: Aarushi murder

  • Aarushi Murder Case Timeline Talwars News Blogs

    I have been following the Aarushi, Hemraj Murder case ever since it was reported.

    Hemraj Aarushi murdered,NOIDA
    Hemraj, Aarushi,Murdered brutally.

    From day one, I have been maintaining that the Talwars are guilty and had posted several blogs on this and a special post on how Tehelka was used by a journalist to cast doubt on the Court to create a sympathy wave for the Talwars.

    Some of my readers have asked me that they have been following my posts on this case and wanted a Time line of this case.

    Here it is.

    Aarushi Talwar, daughter of dentist couple Rajesh and Nupur Talwar, found dead with her throat slit in the bedroom of her Noida home. Nepalese domestic help Hemraj suspected of murder…

    Aarushi murder case: CBI says Rajesh and Nupur Talwar guilty of killing

    – 1 month ago @ dnaindia.com: two used their home computer’s Internet all through the night of the murder, indicating that they were not asleep as claimed by them. Aarushi, 14, was found murdered at her parents’ Noida residence on May 16, 2008. The body of their domestic help …

    Aarushi-Hemraj murder case: Rajesh and Nupur Talwar sentenced to life

    – 14 hours ago @ economictimes.indiatimes.com: The dentist couple were yesterday convicted in the murder of their 14-year-old daughter Aarushi and 45-year-old Hemraj in a case that was awash with allegations of sleaze and sex, police-goof-ups, CBI flip-flops and media bias. The judge also made a …

    Aarushi-Hemraj murder case: The twists and turns since May 16, 2008

    – 1 week ago @ ibnlive.in.com: New Delhi: It is just a week to go for the final verdict in the Aarushi-Hemraj double murder case. It was a case that shocked the nation where a doctor couple was accused of killing its own daughter and domestic help in Noida six years ago. On May 16 …

    Pleas by Talwars Aimed at Delaying Legal Procedures: CBI

    – 10 hours ago @ outlookindia.com: Dentist couple Rajesh and Nupur Talwar, fighting charges in the Noida double murder case, had filed a series of petitions aimed purportedly at delaying the progress of the prosecution in the matter, something to which CBI had time and again raised objections in court.

    Please read my posts on this.

    http://ramanisblog.in/2013/08/31/aarushi-murder-tehelka-in-defence-of-talwars/

  • Aarushi Murder New Evidence Confusion To Mislead.

    Aarushi Murder Case.
    Aarushi Murder Case.

    The Aarushi murder case is now in the final stages, with the prosecutor, having just finished his concluding remarks,

    As I have been following the case regularly, indicating the criminality of the parents in hiding the crime, suppressing crime evidence, having the Police personnel transferred, asking the Doctors who were doing the post mortem to doctor the report and as a last resort have made use of Media by paid write-up in defense of them.

    Now it transpires that the parents were not asleep in their room when their thirteen year old daughter was raped and  brutally murdered, but were busy browsing the Internet.

    Not content with this, they seem to be doing what ever is possible by the moneyed to sow seeds of doubt in the testimonies of the witnesses by a TV  Channel proprietor coming out now saying that there was a footage of a song Playlist which confirmed that there were seven people in the Home of the Talwars while the murder was being committed.

    And the CBI did not use this evidence.

    The intention seems to sow suspicion in the minds of the Judges to exonerate the parents from the hideous crime on the basis of ‘Benefit of Doubt’

    But what they seem to have forgotten is the fact that the CBI closed the Case earlier.

    That Rajesh Talwar did not identify the Body of Hemraj.

    Talwar had the door removed and painted it.

    Had the Police personnel transferred.

    The CBI refuted the allegation that they suppressed the TV Channel evidence by explaining that the information that the suspects(seven people) were listening in to the programme was revealed to them during the Narco Analysis and that the Analysis was discredited.

    Sounds correct.

    What could then have happened on the day of Murder?

    What is the motive?

    Possible scenarios.

    1.Aarushi and Hemraj had illicit liaison , Tawars found it and in a fit of anger and murdered them both.

    2.Mrs. Talwar had illicit relations with Hemraj, found in the act by Aarushi who informed her father and in the scuffle Hemraj was murdered and somehow Aarushi got in the way , got murdered .

    3.Rajesh Talwar’s relation with Aarushi was not paternal ,found out by Mrs. Talwar, in the melee Mrs.Talwar murdered him with the help of Hemraj while Hemraj and Aarushi were the unintended victims,Aaarushi by and Hemraj by Talwar.

    4.The girl was used for immoral purposes and was gang raped and murdered with the parent ‘s connivance.

    All the these theories are preposterous.

    However, as Sherlock Holmes would out it, ‘when you eliminate all the possibilities,what remains is possible though it ma appear to be improbable.

    My earlier post on this, Excerpt.

    The Aarushi double murder case has been bewildering  from the beginning.

    I have been posting on the developments as they unfolded.

    I have in the last post mentioned that Rajesh Talwar’s DNA had to be checked and matched with the DNA found on Aarushi’s pillow.

    This does not have come t pass.

    The CBI though wanted to close due to insufficient evidence in the first attempt’ later charge sheeted the Talwars as the accused.

    Now Tehelka comes with a piece questioning the decision of the CBI Court, Magistrate Court and the Supreme Court on the ground that thirteen witnesses, asked to be examined by the Talwars were not allowed to be examined.

    The article also says that two explosive discoveries on the Narco tests on Krishna were found and states that it would deal with them later in the story.

    But no further information on this is provided.

    The main arguments that the Talwars are not guilty , apart from a syrupy wailing prose are

    1.That “So: two parents with no former history of dysfunctionality or rage are accused of butchering their only child.”

    So if you can be punished only if you have a history of Dysfunctionality or Rage?

    2.That they have not been allowed to cross-examine 13 witnesses, when after the case is over in the first instance and in the second after a thorough examination of witnesses, some 39 of them.

    If one keeps on asking for witnesses as an afterthought after the case is over , or even closed. when will a trial end?.

    3.Insinuation by a Journalist ,As Avirook Sen, a journalist who has been attending the trial regularly, writing sharp reports for the Mumbai Mirror, says, “According to me, the  never intended to go for a trial. But when a trial was ordered, they just had to extemporise the evidence along the way. Now, with each passing day in court, they are getting more and more invested in their own story.’

    4.Why there are no answers for some questions I have raised?On Feb 10,2011.

    Why don’t you answer the following questions?

    Why do you communicate with your daughter through  email when she is in the next room?

    How was the evidence dressed up?

    Why Aarushi’s cuts bore the precision of a Surgeon?

    Why was the doctor asked not to report rape?

    If your conscience is clean you would not be talking like this, rather you would be cooperating with the authorities as a father would.

    Well, a Father would.(http://ramanisblog.in/2011/02/10/indiaa-banana-republic-aarushis-father/)

    Some more question I raised on 7 January 2012,

    http://ramanisblog.in/2013/08/31/aarushi-murder-tehelka-in-defence-of-talwars/

    On October 15, the CBI had told the court that dentists Rajesh and Nupur Talwar dressed up the crime scene and tried to influence a doctor who conducted the autopsy of the teenager.

    two used their home computer’s Internet all through the night of the murder, indicating that they were not asleep as claimed by them.

    Aarushi, 14, was found murdered at her parents’ Noida residence on May 16, 2008. The body of their domestic help Hemraj was found the next day on the terrace of the house.

    The CBI claimed that the suspicion was on the Talwars as they disturbed the crime scene and destroyed evidence on Aarushi’s body.

    Blood stains on the railing of staircases, lock and on the steps were found partially mopped, the CBI had said, adding that this indicated the involvement of the dentist couple in the double murder.

    The Talwars also tried to influence the doctor who performed the post-mortem on Aarushi, the CBI had said. ”

    http://www.dnaindia.com/india/1904796/report-aarushi-murder-case-cbi-says-rajesh-and-nupur-talwar-guilty-of-killing-daughter-and-servant

    http://ramanisblog.in/2012/08/09/dna-on-aarushi-talwars-pillow-covermatch-rajesh-talwars/

    http://www.tehelka.com/framed-the-aarushi-hemraj-murder-case-an-investigation/

    http://mrwhatis.net/aarushis-story.html

  • Aarushi Murder Tehelka In Defence of Talwars

    Aarushi Murder Case.
    Aarushi Murder Case.

    The Aarushi double murder case has been bewildering  from the beginning.

    I have been posting on the developments as they unfolded.

    I have in the last post mentioned that Rajesh Talwar’s DNA had to be checked and matched with the DNA found on Aarushi’s pillow.

    This does not have come t pass.

    The CBI though wanted to close due to insufficient evidence in the first attempt’ later charge sheeted the Talwars as the accused.

    Now Tehelka comes with a piece questioning the decision of the CBI Court, Magistrate Court and the Supreme Court on the ground that thirteen witnesses, asked to be examined by the Talwars were not allowed to be examined.

    The article also says that two explosive discoveries on the Narco tests on Krishna were found and states that it would deal with them later in the story.

    But no further information on this is provided.

    The main arguments that the Talwars are not guilty , apart from a syrupy wailing prose are

    1.That “So: two parents with no former history of dysfunctionality or rage are accused of butchering their only child.”

    So if you can be punished only if you have a history of Dysfunctionality or Rage?

    2.That they have not been allowed to cross-examine 13 witnesses, when after the case is over in the first instance and in the second after a thorough examination of witnesses, some 39 of them.

    If one keeps on asking for witnesses as an afterthought after the case is over , or even closed. when will a trial end?.

    3.Insinuation by a Journalist ,As Avirook Sen, a journalist who has been attending the trial regularly, writing sharp reports for the Mumbai Mirror, says, “According to me, the  never intended to go for a trial. But when a trial was ordered, they just had to extemporise the evidence along the way. Now, with each passing day in court, they are getting more and more invested in their own story.’

    Is no ground for acquittal.

    4.Why there are no answers for some questions I have raised?On Feb 10,2011.

    Why don’t you answer the following questions?

    Why do you communicate with your daughter through  email when she is in the next room?

    How was the evidence dressed up?

    Why Aarushi’s cuts bore the precision of a Surgeon?

    Why was the doctor asked not to report rape?

    If your conscience is clean you would not be talking like this, rather you would be cooperating with the authorities as a father would.

    Well, a Father would.(http://ramanisblog.in/2011/02/10/indiaa-banana-republic-aarushis-father/)

    Some more question I raised on 7 January 2012,

    Right from day one from the date of murder of Aarushi who was brutally murdered in New Delhi, the needle of suspicion has been pointing out the parents.
    The father was communicating with his daughter through emails though they lived in the same house .
    As the child was being murdered, she definitely have raised a hue and cry.
    Yet the parents did not hear them , though they were in their bed room next door!
    The body has been dragged to the top floor of the house and they did not hear any thing.
    The house was locked from the inside, yet there were no signs of forced entry.
    The father asked the Doctor doing the post mortem to tamper with the Report.
    The investigating Officer of the case was transferred.
    The parents made a show of despair ,hanks to TV Channels.

    At last the Supreme Court has sanctioned prosecution.
    It is imperative that the case be disposed of at the earliest(http://ramanan50.blogspot.in/2012/01/arushis-parents-to-be-indicted-at-last.html)

    4.Who had the Investigating officer removed, the domestic helps?

    5.There a whine that Narco Analysis Test results are not allowed  in the court.

    So…?

    The amount of power one can pull through Media is disgusting.

    Read the complete set of stories on Aarushi case, from my sites and elsewhere and decide for yourself whether a Father and Mother would have behaved the way the Talwars did, without answering any of the basic questions any one can sk, no legal training or Journalistic acumen is required.

    http://ramanisblog.in/2012/08/09/dna-on-aarushi-talwars-pillow-covermatch-rajesh-talwars/

    http://www.tehelka.com/framed-the-aarushi-hemraj-murder-case-an-investigation/

    http://mrwhatis.net/aarushis-story.html

  • India,a banana Republic-Aarushi’s Father.

    Why don’t you answer the following questions?

    Why do you communicate with your daughter through  email when she is in the next room?

    How was the evidence dressed up?

     

    Why Aarushi’s cuts bore the precision of a Surgeon?

    Why was the doctor asked not to report rape?

    If your conscience is clean you would not be talking like this, rather you would be cooperating with the authorities as a father would.

    Well, a Father would.

    New Delhi: “I should not have been born in this country. It is nothing but a banana republic.”

    This was how a shattered Rajesh Talwar, father of Aarushi, reacted today shortly after the CBI special court ordered that he and his wife Nupur be tried for the murder of the teenager in May 2008.

    Rajesh said there is “no law in India” and that it is “nothing but a banana republic.”

    “The system is just nothing. I am sorry to say. I should not have been born in this country. I want the country, media to wake up. It is not fair…” he told a TV channel.

    Rajesh said he has tried everything to prove his innocence for the past two-and-a-half years.

    http://in.news.yahoo.com/aarushi-case–india-a–banana-republic—says-father-.html

    Aarushi Murder untold Story.

    A disturbing sexual angle has emerged in the murder of Aarushi Talwar, 14. Crucial facts left out from her post-mortem report suggest that her private parts were “extraordinarily dilated”. But there were no signs of rape. These facts, established by the CBI after they questioned the doctor who performed the post-mortem, give a new twist to the case.”The vaginal orifice of the deceased was unduly large and mouth of cervix was visible,” says the CBI’s closure report.

    Her private parts were cleaned. This caused water stains on the bedsheet. There was no semen on the bedsheet. But the pyjamas Aarushi wore did not have water stains on it. This shows that the crime scene was dressed up. The CBI believes Aarushi may have been killed elsewhere and the body placed on her bed.
    parallel investigation by Headlines Today reveals that the chairperson of the National Commission on Women (NCW) Girija Vyas allegedly scuttled a probe into the Aarushi’s murder by a two-member NCW committee. Soon after the killing, this committee visited the Talwar house in Jalvayu Vihar, Noida, to investigate. Former NCW member Nirmala Venkatesh alleges that as soon as they stepped into Hemraj’s room, she got five calls from Vyas, asking her to stop the probe. Vyas initially denied there was an inquiry and that a committee was formed. She later admitted that there was, but said the report was not made public because the CBI was about to investigate.

    These sensational revelations fly in the face of the CBI’s closure report. Last month, the CBI sought the special court’s permission to close the double murder case because it could not solve it.

    Though the CBI has been unable to nail the accused, its investigations have completely ruled out the possibility of outsiders having killed Aarushi and domestic help Hemraj Banjade. Circumstantial evidence points to the complicity of those inside. The crime scene was methodically “dressed up”or cleansed of all evidence which could implicate the Talwars. An expert from the forensic science laboratory, Gandhinagar, who inspected the crime scene, says that the crime had been committed by someone “very close to Aarushi”.

    Nobody except the killer or killers, of course, knows what exactly happened in the Talwar residence during the six crucial hours between 12 midnight and 6 a.m. on May 16, 2008, when both Hemraj and Aarushi were brutally murdered within an hour. Aarushi was bludgeoned on her forehead and her throat slit with a small, sharp object. So was Hemraj.

    A reconstruction of the crime, however, increasingly points to an inside hand. The assailants had gained easy access to the flat because there were no signs of forced entry. They killed Aarushi and Hemraj, moved their bodies around the flat and even stayed behind for drinks. The parents of Aarushi, Nupur and Rajesh Talwar, seem to have slept through an incredible amount of activity in their small flat. They claimed their bedroom door was shut and the air-conditioner turned on.

    The murderer dragged Hemraj’s body to the terrace using a sheet. The body was cursorily covered with a cooler lid and a bedsheet on a clothesline. The murderers then locked the terrace door and re-entered the house. They even seemed to know where the Talwars’ mini-bar was-behind a wooden panel near the dining table. They drank from a bottle of whiskey and left it on the dining table. The bottle had bloodstains of both victims.

    At around 3.43 a.m., the Internet router in Aarushi’s room was switched off. That means that somebody entered her room nearly three hours after her murder. Whoever it was, failed to raise the alarm or even spot her body.

    At 6.01 a.m., housemaid Bharti arrived. She rang the doorbell four times. Normally, Hemraj, the domestic help, would open the door, but this time Nupur opened it. Rajesh was also awake. This was unusual because the couple were late risers. The iron grill door at the entrance was locked from outside, so Nupur threw the keys from the balcony to Bharti. Three minutes later, when Bharti entered, she found the couple sobbing. “Dekho Hemraj ne kya kar diya (look what Hemraj has done)”. Aarushi was found on the bed in a pool of blood. Bharti rushed out to inform the neighbours. Hemraj’s room had an independent entry and opened into the flat from inside.

    Another strange incident happened around this time. Nupur called Hemraj’s cellphone from her landline at 6.01 a.m. The call was immediately disconnected. This means the dead servant’s phone was attended by someone near the crime scene. Inexplicably, both Hemraj’s and Aarushi’s cellphones disappeared. Hemraj’s phone was never found but Aarushi’s Nokia N72 was found on a dirt track by a housemaid near Noida’s Sadarpur area a fortnight later. Its memory was wiped clean. The cellphone was a crucial piece of evidence.

    Aarushi would usually be up chatting with her friends until well past midnight. On the night of May 15, her cellphone was inactive after 9.10 p.m. At around midnight, her friend Anmol called on the Talwar landline because he could not get through her cellphone. There was no response. Anmol then sent an SMS to her cellphone at around 12.30. This SMS was not received by Aarushi’s phone.

    What were the Talwars doing before the murders? According to the CBI closure report, after reaching home at 9.30 p.m., they dined with Aarushi, then took a few pictures on a new digital camera they bought for Aarushi as a birthday gift and retired by around 11 p.m. Around this time, Nupur came to Aarushi’s room to switch on the Internet router. Aarushi was reading a book.

    The parents controlled access to Aarushi’s room by locking it; the keys to her room would usually lie by Nupur’s bedside. Nupur told the police that she was not sure whether she locked Aarushi’s door the last time she went to her room. Rajesh received a call from the US on his landline at this time. This indicated that his ringer was not silent. He surfed the Internet, sent some emails, surveyed stock market sites and some dentistry sites. He sent his last email at 11.57 p.m. before presumably going to sleep.

    The following morning, the bunch of keys to the flat and terrace were found on the bed in Hemraj’s room by Nupur. Aarushi’s bedroom keys were found in the living room. It was the only set of house keys, so it is still not clear how the Talwars were locked from the outside. The police arrived an hour later, at 7.15 a.m. They were met by a crowd inside. There were 15 people in the living room and five-six people in the Talwars’ bedroom. Only Aarushi’s room was empty. The crime scene was completely trampled upon.

    The “Hemraj killed Aarushi” theory was gospel for a full day. Rajesh repeatedly told the police officers to pursue Hemraj and not to waste time in his flat. He dissuaded them from opening the locked terrace door and even offered the policemen Rs 25,000 to rush to Hemraj’s village in Nepal.

    The CBI and police mention they saw the concerted efforts by the Talwars to put the blame on Hemraj as a diversionary tactic. Meanwhile, doctors visiting the Talwars saw bloodstains on the handle of the locked terrace door. They also saw wiped bloody footmarks and blood stains on the upper staircase. Rajesh was asked for the keys but he went inside his residence after seeing the blood-stained door handle. The police failed to open the door for a full day.
    Aarushi’s body was taken for a post-mortem in Noida at about 9 a.m. and her last rites performed late in the evening. The Talwars’ domestic staff showed undue haste in thoroughly cleaning up floors and walls of Aarushi’s room with soap and water. Aarushi’s blood-stained mattress was dumped on the terrace belonging to neighbour Puneet Tandon.

    Meanwhile, when the post-mortem report was being written between 3 p.m. and 6 p.m. on May 16, a telephonic loop was created between Rajesh’s elder brother Dinesh Talwar, family friend Dr Sushil Chaudhury, K.K. Gautam, a retired deputy superintendent of police, and an unidentified number. Dinesh would call Chaudhury who would call Gautam. The latter would dial an unidentified number. This sequence was then reversed. This loop was created six times that evening. The CBI claims that it was done to delete references to “rape” in Aarushi’s post-mortem report.

    Some 28 fingerprint samples were lifted from the scene of crime and handed over to the CBI on May 20. This was 10 days before the case was formally handed over to the CBI. Most of the fingerprints, especially those on the whiskey bottle, were smudged.

    Between 9 a.m. and 10 a.m. on May 17, this loop was repeated twice. Soon after these calls were made, Gautam arrived at the Talwar house and asked for the terrace door to be opened after examining the site of crime. Before calling the local police to open the door, he called a top Uttar Pradesh police officer and then his journalist friends so that the door is opened in media glare. Gautam told them that there was likely to be an interesting discovery.
    When the local police arrived at the Talwar residence, the media was already there. The keys to the terrace were still missing, so the lock was broken to enter the terrace. Hemraj’s body was discovered. However, vital clues were missing-the blood-soaked clothes of the perpetrators, the cloth used to clean the floor and the sheet on which Hemraj’s body was dragged.

    Was there a definite ploy to hide Hemraj’s body? And why leave it on the terrace? CBI sleuths believe the body was hidden on the roof by the murderer for disposal later. But the media glare made it virtually impossible to spirit away the body, hence they changed the plan. It may prove as difficult for the CBI to walk away from one of India’s most sensational whodunits.

    http://in.news.yahoo.com/the-untold-story-of-arushi-murder-case.html

  • CBI court says yes to narco test for Talwars

    Considering the background of the case,the fact that father and daughter have been communicating with each other through email tough they were living in the same house,that they could not hear a thing at the time of murder, the fact that the couple had locked themselves in their bed room, the relation ship of the Aarushi family with their friend’s family and the way they went about orchestrating media support, the needle of suspicion is definitely points out the Talwars.

    A Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)’s designated court in Ghaziabad has given its go-ahead to the agency to conduct narco test on Rajesh Talwar and Nupur Talwar, parents of teenager Aarushi who was found murdered in her Noida flat on May 16, 2008.
    However, no particular date has been fixed up for the said tests.
    In its order released on Tuesday, the designated court ordered the narco tests to be conducted at the Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) at Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat.
    The court also ordered a complete medical examination of Dr. Rajesh Talwar by a medical practitioner to ascertain his health condition as fit before the tests were conducted.
    The Talwars’s lawyers in an argument before the court on Monday had stated that Rajesh Talwar suffered from Asthma since childhood and undergoing the narco-test could be detrimental to his health.
    Quoting Tuesday’s order, the court said that CBI was given the go ahead since the scientific tests were not related to any accused and under section 160 and 161 of CrPC, the investigating officer is free to conduct the tests of any person whoever he thinks has knowledge about the facts and circumstances related to the case.

    http://www.hindustantimes.com/News-Feed/northindia/CBI-court-says-yes-to-narco-test-for-Talwars/Article1-494181.aspx