The Mudgal Committee appointed to probe into allegations of IPL 2013 Match Fixing, has transcripts revealing conversations that indicate PL match was fixed by Indian Captain MS Dhoni and Suresh Raina.
What can come out of this Probe and the Committee Report?
“A report of details revealed during the interrogation of a bookie, known by the name of ‘Kitty’, alias Uttham Jain, was submitted to the Committee by IPS Officer G Sampath Kumar.
The report alleges that more than half of the matches played during IPL 2013 could have been fixed and Indian Cricket team players MS Dhoni and Suresh Raina knew about the wrongdoings.
The report provides incriminating evidence suggesting that the match between Chennai Super Kings and Rajasthan Royals played on May 12, 2013 was FIXED.
The report quotes phone transcripts between Gurunath Meiyappan and Vindoo Dara Singh. The two can be heard discussing bets on the match between CSK and RR on May 12, 2013…
Meiyappan tells Vindoo that CSK will score around 140 runs. Later, CSK scored 141 runs in the match.
‘During the match, Gurunath placed bets of Rs.1.4 crore against CSK and confidently told Vindoo that Royals will win. In a conversation at 21:09 on May 12, 2013, stating that he has already placed bets of Rs. 20 lakh, Gurunath asks Vindoo to place Rs. 30 lakh more on Rajasthan. He says, “RR is winning pakka”,’ the Mail Today report quoted.
Meiyappan and Aggarwal were approached by a man from RAJASTHAN at Radisson Blu Hotel, Egmor. The report published in Mail Today reveals that Meiyappan informed Kitty that a discussion is going in regarding fixing the match between CSK and RR, scheduled to take place on May 12, 2013.
A second meeting took place on April 27, 2013 and Vikram Aggarwal informed Kitty that a deal was WORKED OUT.
‘Later after dinner party Meiyappan has informed that Chennai Super Kings MS Dhoni has agreed to play as per plan and his team will score 140 runs and this was communicated to somebody ( Sanjay) in Jaipur over phone by Vikram Agarwal when Kitty was nearby,’ the Mail Today report quoted.
In a separate conversation between Aggarwal and Vindoo- ‘Vikram Agarwal told him [ Kitty] that there was negotiation for match- fixing between Rajasthan Royals and Chennai Super Kings and Meiyappan has to communicate to Chennai Super Kings captain MS Dhoni and few others for finalisation,’ the report submitted with Mudgal Committee was quoted by Mail Today.
There have been reports in the media that the Indian Cricket Captain of all the three forms of the game is/was involved in a Company that promotes Cricketers.
Rhiti clients
The Company RHITI manages the players Suresh Raina,Ravindra Jadeja ,RP Singh and Pragyan Ojha, among others.
It is reported that Dhoni had/has 15% stake in the Comapny.
As MS Dhoni is the Captain of the Indian Cricket Team the charge is that of ‘Conflict of Interest’
1.Dhoni is legally correct unless there is Clause in the Contract with the BCCI which prohibits him from holding such an investment.
On his side there is a point that owning or investing in a Company that promotes players are not wrong as he alone does not decide the composition of the team.
There is no law prohibiting owning a Company which happens to be in the same line activity.
If the same Logic is to be applied,many of us may not be to invest at all.
If Dhoni is wrong what about Sunil Gavaskar, who at one time a part of Professional Management Group,which manages’managed Cricket Players?
Dhoni is also Vice President of India Cements.
Even this is conflict of Interest as India Cements owns CSK.
This could not have been with out the knowledge of the BCCI.
Why did not BCCI object to it?
There is a consternation that Parthiv Patel, RP Singh have not been given adequate chances.
That’s a laugh.
No body had been given as many chances as these two.
The others too have not performed.
The long and short of it is,that Dhoni may be legally correct.
Morally?
On this count ,right from Sonai Gandhi, Sharad Pawar down the line to Dalmiya are wrong.
See the image above and coun the people who have stakes in IPL.
The funny thing is that nothing is said about Rajasthan Royals whose players have been arrested and RR has been absolved of any wrong doing with out any nquiry!
Money and Morals are poles apart.
Story:
In 2010, he turned it into a business partnership by signing up with Pandey to market him for a whopping Rs 210 crore-deal over three years. It now transpires that the relationship went much deeper: Dhoni owns a 15 per cent stake in the firm, even if it was only for a brief while, as they are so feebly claiming.
Not surprisingly, Indian cricket has responded angrily, with players and officials crying foul. The company, incidentally, also manages Suresh Raina, Ravindra Jadeja, Pragyan Ojha and RP Singh (who denied being part of Rhiti at the moment), four players who have been almost regular fixtures in all three formats of the game for Team India.
More than that, the preferential treatment that Raina and Jadeja have enjoyed under his dispensation at Chennai Super Kings has always seemed strange. Jadeja, in fact, was acquired for an incredible annual fee of $2 million. One can imagine the killing Rhiti made when the deal was stuck.
TOI spoke to a cross-section of players and BCCI officials and almost all of them conceded that the skipper of the Indian team holding shares in an agency that manages players in his team itself was not an ideal situation. “It should not be allowed because the captain does influence the selection of as team; in fact, overseas, he and the coach have the sole authority on team selection. Now, I can only think of all the instances that looked like ‘wrong’ selections in recent times,” former Board secretary Jayawant Lele said.
“It is better that the BCCI deals with the issue quickly before it gets any bigger,” said former India off-spinner Erapalli Prasanna.
Dhoni has shown a preference for certain players in the team, and this revelation has only added fuel to the fire, with many connecting the dots. According to his critics, many talented players have been dumped during his reign without a fair opportunity. Dig deeper into first class cricket and you can cull out those names: batsmen Manoj Tiwary, Saurabh Tiwary, all-rounder Abhishek Nayar, seamer Dhawal Kulkarni, leg-spinner Amit Mishra, wicketkeeper Parthiv Patel, to start with.
“With him, it’s a question of like and dislike. If you are disliked by him, good luck to you! You can keep performing in domestic cricket, it doesn’t matter” said a player.
Now that Team India has started losing there are criticisms and suggestions galore from every one.
Why should I be left behind?
This is my take.
Team India.
Bowling attack , especially the pace attack is toothless.
Spinning department is weak with Harbhajan (who has over 400 wickets) over the hill, and the replacements are not up to the rigors of International Stage.
Sachin Tedulkar is past his best(!?),becoming nervous in the nineties.
Rahul Dravid , though played well,is on the way out.
You must be logged in to post a comment.